Five Dhikrs of Muhammad Ghawth: Posture and Breath
The five dhikrs attributed to Hazrat Shaikh Muhammad Ghawth (d. 970 AH / 1562–63 CE) are the best-known technical residue of the Shattari encounter with yogic practice in India. Preserved in the manuscript tradition of the Bahr al-Hayat and summarised in Qazi Moinuddin Ahmad’s 1963 thesis, they combine a fixed seat, regulated breath, and a sacred syllable — always, in the sources’ own framing, in the service of dhikr, the remembrance of Allah. This post describes them at the scholarly level the subject demands: what they are called, what general character each has, and what Islamic function the tradition assigns them. It is a historical account, not a manual.
The Five Dhikrs in the Order’s Literature
Ahmad’s thesis draws these five practices from the Bahr al-Hayat manuscript, presenting them as practices Shaikh Muhammad Ghawth recommended to his disciples. The book is Ghawth’s Persian adaptation of the Sanskrit Amrtakunda, and the five sit inside a work whose larger trajectory is already Islamic: where the Sanskrit source invoked yogini powers, Ghawth substituted Sufi dhikr material, as modern comparison of the versions establishes. The five appear in a document that has already passed the tradition’s filter.
Each of the five couples three elements: a defined bodily seat, a coupling of breath with a syllable or syllables, and the intention of remembrance. That triad is not borrowed whole from either side: fixed seats and breath-syllable coupling were known in Sufi method literature before Ghawth — habs-i dam, regulation and brief retention of breath, appears in earlier Chishti dhikr contexts — while the specific posture-syllable pairings show the yogic input clearly. The tradition’s own category is Sufi: forms of dhikr, assisted by posture and breath, aimed at the settling of the heart in Allah’s remembrance and the discipline of murakaba.
The Practices, as the Sources Record Them
What follows is the thesis’s own list, kept at description level: no duration, count, or instruction, because the living application of such discipline belongs to the murshid, not the page — as the station of the murshid requires in every matter of method.
- Dhikr Hans. A cross-legged seated posture in which the head and the back are held on one level; the syllables “Han” and “Soo” are coupled, in the text’s account, with the outward and the inward breath. The name itself echoes the breath-sound vocabulary shared across the Indic and Persianate worlds.
- Dhikr Alkah. A seat upon the heels with the fists stacked beneath the chin and the body compressed; the thesis records that attention is drawn to the navel region in the rhythm of the breath. The compression of the frame serves the gathered, inward posture of the reciter.
- Dhikr Kahaktehi. In a posture the text names Karanba Asana, the head, feet and hands are brought together; the breath is regulated, and the mouth and jaw set in a manner the source describes. The Sanskrit naming is itself evidence of the transmission the thesis documents.
- Dhikr Naranjan. In a posture the text calls Gurba Asin — head between the thighs, elbows upon the thighs, hands upon the ears — with the breath, in the source’s phrase, “revolved in the belly.” The enclosure of the ears, in Sufi reading, serves the silencing of outer noise for the work of the heart.
- Dhikr Chagni. The thighs joined, one hand upon the other, the seat firm, and a rotation of the eyes described in the manuscript. This ocular element most clearly mirrors yogic gazing techniques — yet the tradition’s frame for it remains remembrance, not sight of hidden things.
Read together, the list is what scholars call the classic Sufi-yoga hybrid: seat, breath, syllable. But the sources never release the triad from its Islamic anchor: the syllable serves the name, the breath the gathering of attention, the posture the stability of the reciter. Nothing in the five aims at powers of the body or visions commanded by technique; the goal named throughout is dhikr itself.
Why the Breath Is Regulated in Sufi Dhikr
Western readers often ask whether this breath regulation constitutes pranayama — an independent yogic science with its own cosmology of channels and winds. Inside the Shattari frame, it does not: breath regulation serves murakaba and the steadiness of dhikr, disciplining the door through which the attention escapes. The vocabulary is already Islamic before Ghawth — habs-i dam belonged to Chishti method literature under guidance — while Ghawth’s circle added a more technical repertoire of seats and couplings from the hatha tradition of the Vindhyachal region where, the thesis records, the early Shattari chain lived among Hindu mystics.
Pranayama in its own system is a road toward yogic ends; breath inside dhikr has no such career. It is an instrument of attention, subordinate to the tongue’s remembrance and the heart’s presence, bounded by the rulings that govern every act of worship: pure body, lawful time, sincere intention. The wider disciplines of seated retreat and extended attention belong to the path compared in tawajjuh, chilla and khalwa, where posture and duration are the guide’s assignment, never the seeker’s invention.
Described, Not Prescribed: the Shariah Boundary of This Account
This post describes practices preserved in the order’s historical literature; it does not prescribe them. The five dhikrs were transmitted within a master-disciple relationship, under a murshid, inside the shari’ah of the path — body purified, intention guarded, method assigned, state watched. A seeker today who wishes any discipline of posture or breath must do so only under a trustworthy guide who judges it lawful and fitting. Technique never substitutes for ibadah, taqwa, or the ordinary obligations of the shari’ah; it is a means whose permissibility is judged, not a reader’s right. Nor does any posture or breath pattern guarantee states or openings — every genuine opening is attributed to Allah’s grant alone. The heart’s work is served first by the acts already obligatory: prayer, Qur’an, and the dhikr of tongue and heart in the order’s daily wird, as taught in dhikr-e-qalbi, the invocation of the heart. Nothing here is an instruction to adopt yogic practice.
What the Encounter Means for the Reader Today
The five are historically valuable because they show the filter at work on living technique: yogic vocabulary translated into the language of Allah’s names and of fatḥ — opening — granted from above. Later Sufi voices, examined elsewhere in this series, would question how much of this repertoire the path needed, judging yogic practice effective perhaps but surpassed by the practice the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ himself established. The honest reading holds both notes: a genuine record of encounter, and a debate always carried inside the tradition it entered. For the seeker, the living inheritance of the Shattariyya remains its wird, its dhikr, and its discipline of the heart under the guide — not the museum of technique its books preserve.
Sources and Further Reading
- Qazi Moinuddin Ahmad, History of the Shattari Silsilah (PhD thesis, 1963) — the summary of the five dhikrs from the Bahr al-Hayat manuscript, ff. 26–34, presented as practices recommended by Shaikh Muhammad Ghawth to his disciples.
- Carl W. Ernst — scholarship on the Bahr al-Hayat as Ghawth’s Persian adaptation of the Amrtakunda, including the replacement of yogini-summoning material with Sufi dhikr.
- Parvaneh Khodamoradi and Carl W. Ernst, Religions 15(3):359 (2024) — the modern field study of Shattari method literature and its Indic context.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the five dhikrs attributed to Muhammad Ghawth?
They are five practices — Hans, Alkah, Kahaktehi, Naranjan and Chagni — which Qazi Moinuddin Ahmad’s thesis records from the Bahr al-Hayat manuscript as practices Shaikh Muhammad Ghawth recommended to his disciples. Each couples a fixed seat, a regulated breath, and a sacred syllable, framed by the sources as dhikr, remembrance of Allah: posture and breath serve the steadiness of the reciter, not any independent yogic end.
Did Muhammad Ghawth copy yoga wholesale?
No. The scholarly verdict is assimilation under an Islamic filter. Posture-syllable pairings entered his method literature; the cosmology that powered the source practices did not. In the Bahr al-Hayat itself, the chapter on summoning yogini goddesses was replaced with Sufi dhikr material. Technique passed; polytheism was refused.
Why is the breath regulated in Sufi dhikr?
Inside the tradition, breath regulation — habs-i dam, already known in earlier Chishti method literature — serves murakaba and the steadiness of remembrance. It is never an independent pranayama science, and its permissibility and application are judged by the guide within the rulings that govern every act of worship.
Should a seeker today try these postures?
No — they are described here, not prescribed. Application requires a murshid and belongs to the shari’ah of the path: purified body, sincere intention, method assigned by the guide, state watched over. Nothing here guarantees results or substitutes for the obligatory acts of worship or the order’s lawful daily wird.
Disclaimer: the practices described in this post are preserved in the order’s historical literature and are described, not prescribed. Their application requires a murshid and follows the shari’ah of the path; technique never substitutes for ibadah, taqwa, or the rulings of the shari’ah, and no posture or breath pattern guarantees states or results. Nothing here is an instruction to adopt yogic practice. Questions about the Trust’s programmes are welcome on +91 97317 17703 or at info@alhashmi.org.